The death of media relations?

Elizabeth Albrycht paints a depressing picture on the current state of media relations.

“When I do media relations, I am representing small, emerging high-tech companies. Not the IBMs of the world, who the press pretty much has to cover. When I did PR for IBM at least editors would listen to you for a minute or two. With unknown companies it is virtually impossible.”

There’s some excellent comments on the post:

Trevor Cook:  “More broadly, media relations for small clients has always been hard work and it gets harder all the time with more companies chasing the same few pages. Many end up disappointed.”

Mike Manuel: “As a result, one of the most important PR takeaways from the dot com boom fell to the wayside � creativity. I think a healthy dose of creativity has been missing the last few years and it needs to be re-infused in all media relations efforts.”

Elizabeth comes to the conclusion that she’ll increasingly be involved in the marketing communications side of the house. I think it’s a great observation.  In my view, whilst media relations will continue to play a very important role, the future success of Public Relations depends upon practitioners’ ability to take their undoubted skills in communication, strategy and implementation and apply them to a much wider range of areas.

The prime suspects right now are any area of online communications whether it be websites, newsletters, corporate blogs, search engine optimization etc. The common theme is these areas require an understanding of how to communicate be it with staff, media, analysts, customers prospects, business partners etc..

Media relations isn’t going anywhere (in fact blog relations may even bolster what we call “media” relations) but we all need to continously understand the new tools that are becoming available and how they impact our professional life.

 

Measuring Blog Relations…

Kathy E. Gill has penned an interesting research paper entitled “How can we measure the influence of the blogosphere?” (PDF). As the title suggests it looks at how we might measure the reach and influence of individual blogs.

One of the problems I have with much of the current writing on blog measurement is that it treats blogs in the same manner as the PR industry views journalism. I think that’s a little shortsighted.

While influential blogs are normally widely read, it’s not purely a question of the pure “circulation” or the volume of links. 

Not only does this approach ignore many smaller, yet possibly more effective blogs but it does nothing to help us understand the potential of using weblogs as a means of communicating with your audience(s), which can often be just as valuable.

The Internet provides us with a great opportunity to measure the performance of most marketing activities.  This measurement should be applied to blog relations.

Research the most relevant blogs – are there blogs focused on your industry? What are your customers and partners reading?

Understand the blogger’s agenda – even the most independent blogger has opinions

Respect the blogger – Bloggers don’t necessarily play by the well established PR-Media rule book.  You should be very careful before you pitch.  Understand the blogger’s agenda and modus operandi. Don’t spam them.

Measure, measure, measure – when you work with a blogger and they post a story on your firm, track the number of referrals that a post on a particular blog provides to your website.

Roll your own – would a blog be a useful communications tool for your own business? Do you have views on your industry? Can you commit the time required?

Review – once your blog relations program is underway, review it.  Find out what worked and what didn’t.. and why.

Blog relations can yield significant results. A couple of years ago we pitched four bloggers on a free utility we were providing.  We did this prior to a press release on the utility and we measured the response to the bloggers’ posts as best we could.

The result was that we got a great understanding of the respective influence of the various blogs.  We also managed to get over a million people to use the free utility.  In addition, the blog posts got the utility published in mainstream media such as the New York Times and the San Jose Mercury News as well as a large number of trade magazines.  Blog Relations can work if you take a well planned approach to target blogs that are relevant to your business. 

Footnote:

The original link to Kathy E. Gill’s research is from Steve Rubel.

Mike Manuel also has some thoughts on blog measurement.

The collision of blogging and the media (Boston Globe)

Today’s Boston Globe takes a look at the collision of blogs and the traditional media. the piece is focused on the political side of the house.

“Their (bloggers) distance from professional media, in part, is what gives blogs their identity. Bloggers’ voices are often more conversational, and profane, than newspaper or magazine fare. And while blogs have been known to amplify little-noticed news events, such as Senator Trent Lott’s 2002 praise of his colleague Strom Thurmond, blog postings don’t always hew to old-school standards of sourcing and fact-checking. There’s usually no editing at all, which many bloggers take as a point of pride.”

 

The hidden danger of blogs

There’s a very amusing article in the UK Times on the potential danger of embarrasment for babies born to parents who blog.

“So put yourself in the place of Jake, 28 days old today, whose mother, Nicola, has been keeping a diary of his birth on www.babythoughts.co.uk. Imagine a future employer or girlfriend reading the entry for Monday, April 12: ‘Ew. Jake just peed on my arm! It�s like a fountain that never ends. How can such a tiny baby have such a big bladder?’�

PR news from around the web..

 You have to love coincidences… After posting my rant on the educated consumer I spotted a story about how Internet “strategy” firm I-ology has launched an online PR service.

Trish Bear, I-ology president and CEO. “In talking with clients every day, I continue to hear the need for effective communication programs that not only help build brand awareness, but that also directly boost bottom line results. As arguably the most cost-effective marketing tool available, the addition of a public relations line of business is the perfect next step in I-ology’s commitment to our clients’ success.”

 I also spotted a very strange story in the UK’s Brand Republic.  The story concerns eBay’s appointment of a PR chief in the UK.  Why’s it strange?  Well all the color commentary is provided by the ex-PR head of one of their competitors. Unusual.

Alex Czajkowski, a former director of marketing for internet auction company, QXL, is full of praise for what is, for him, a former rival brand: ‘eBay is integral to the fabric of America, like Coke, IBM and Pepsi.

 There’s also an interesting feud going on in Canada with the man who billed 3,600 hours in a year. Now that’s efficient time management…

 

The dreaded era of the educated consumer…

The entrepreneurs of the Internet boom sold us all on a vision where we’d never again have to leave our bedrooms or even get dressed.

We all bought this vision of the total online world, when in fact if we had stepped outside the hype and remembered the lessons from history we would have realised that oftentimes new innovations take their place alongside the incumbents rather than replacing them.

So in the PR world, the Internet is now another medium which sits comfortably alongside our newpapers and magazines, our television, cable and radio.

What the Internet has done is to make the job of a PR practitioner more complex than before.  We’ve a host of new tools, thousands of new media sources and our greatest challenge yet: creating conversations with our audience.

As all the marketing disciplines have become more sophisticated, so has the consumer.  Where the Internet was heralded as a means of creating instantaneous sales (and in some cases such as books it has), consumers today expect companies to work harder for their dollars.

Think about my recent purchase of a PDA as a case in point.

In the past, I might have got a couple of brochures from some manufacturers, visited a couple of retail outlets and made a decision. Today that purchase process is far more complex.

I’ll search for all the manufacturers. I’ll go to all their sites and read their literature.  I’ll visit the relevant magazines and read the reviews, visit mailing lists, consumer opinion sites. I’ll still pop into the retail store and finally I’ll make my “educated” opinion. Then, once I’ve parted with my cash and my post-purchase cognitive dissonance sets in, I’ll re-visit my chosen vendor’s website to be reassured that I made the right decision.

That is a longer and more demanding sales cycle.

It seems to me that as the ticker price rises, the purchase process for the educated consumer becomes longer and more complex with the Internet.  That’s a real business issue.

So how is Public Relations responding to this new demanding consumer?

I think the jury’s out, but given the growing need for PR to make a direct contribution to an organization’s bottom line, it is something that every practitioner should be thinking about.

We need to understand the complex purchase process and how we can communicate more effectively during that process.

Then there’s the Cluetrain effect.

Every company needs official content, data sheets, backgrounders etc., but there is also a growing need for companies to reach out and connect with their customers. The Cluetrain declaration that markets aren’t about products or services but about conversations, is more relevant today than when it was published.

Organizations that can connect with customers in a real and meaningful way have a strong advantage over those that hide behind corporate speak.  Weblogs offer one tactic to help firms reach out, but weblogs continue to be in their infancy and as a result, firms are struggling to understand how they can be best deployed.

Trevor Cook reports that Microsoft, a company facing a challenging market, now has over 400 employee blogs. Many of these blogs are well written and do show a positive human side to Microsoft.  However, many are written by individuals who have drank a little too much Kool-Aid and are a little too fond of quoting the “great human resource benefits” at the company.

I have no concrete answers to these questions. It’s too early and I’m always suspicious of people who declare they know the code.

However here’s an exercise for you.

How well do you understand the typical purchase process for your client or employer’s product? Do you know and understand where those customers find information? Are your PR activities tailored to meet those needs? Are you trying to create conversations?

The Internet is all about communication and therefore it’s all about Public Relations. PR can play a central role in helping firms deal with the educated consumer. It’s a great opportunity.

We’re all busy, we’re all under resourced and over worked (A great illustration for the dreaded “Sharpen the Saw” metaphor).

However, sometimes it is useful to step back and look at the business problem, it could help make your PR programs more effective and a prominent contributor to the bottom line. The difficult part is that the media and the audience continues to change.  Success will require some new approaches.

 

Los Angeles PR turmoil continues…

The current snafu around Public Relations services being provided to the City of Los Angeles has taken an interesting twist, with news that Los Angeles Mayor Jame Hahn has ordered that City departments should halt any current negotiations with PR firms and if possible break existing contracts.

This follows news that Fleishman-Hillard has cancelled its existing contracts with City departments…