The problem with a well executed, well financed marketing/PR campaign is that your success can often be counter-productive if the product or service doesn’t meet expectations.
One of the best examples of this was the 1985 launch of New Coke. Here was one of the world’s most loved brands
launching a newer, and according to taste tests, better product. It got saturation media coverage around the world and the launch was executed to perfection. Only one problem, consumers hated it.
It was launched in April and by July it was pulled. People didn’t like it and the story of the failure of New Coke got more press inches than the initial success. Coke spent millions and learned an important lesson… or did they?
Now Coke is facing it’s Tylenol crisis. After a successful, �7 million launch of its Dasani bottled water on the UK market, it has had to pull the water because traces of bromate, a cancer-causing chemical have been found in the water. Furthermore it has transpired they were simply taking common tap water and putting it through a “purification process”. This process which at the launch was described as a “highly sophisticated purification process based on Nasa spacecraft technology”, was in reality the same process found in the most popular domestic water purification units
This is clearly the nightmare situation for the PR professional, particularly when the tap water doesn’t have bromate and there’s a cost differential of 0.03 pence for the tap water and 95 pence for a half litre of Dasani.
It’s also an interesting example of how the geographical barriers for crises are falling, this story has been covered all over the globe: UK Story, US Story, Australian Story, New Zealand story, African Story.
From the BBC:
Judith Snyder, brand PR manager for Dasani, confirmed “municipal” water supplies were used but said the source was “irrelevant” because it “doesn’t affect the end result… We would never say tap water isn’t drinkable….It’s just that Dasani is as pure as water can get – there are different levels of purity.”
It looks like Dasani has a different level of purity alright. Another example of how good PR and marketing can be wasted if the product doesn’t live up to expectations. A true PR nightmare.